criticize Case definition When the team reached the field, we made a very broad case definition as a method to include as many diseased cases as possible for blood sample collection for testing and confirmation. Our field case definition was any patient who developed a sudden high-grade fever ≥38 ◦C with or without bleeding, jaundice, vomiting or prostration after October 1. We used this case definition to guide our hospital visits, to facilitate active household case searching and to assist with clinical records revision.
Question
criticize Case definition When the team reached the field, we made a very broad case definition as a method to include as many diseased cases as possible for blood sample collection for testing and confirmation. Our field case definition was any patient who developed a sudden high-grade fever ≥38 ◦C with or without bleeding, jaundice, vomiting or prostration after October 1. We used this case definition to guide our hospital visits, to facilitate active household case searching and to assist with clinical records revision.
Solution
The case definition provided seems to be quite comprehensive, but there are a few areas that could be criticized or improved:
-
Broadness: While the broadness of the case definition allows for the inclusion of many potential cases, it may also lead to the inclusion of cases that are not relevant to the study. This could potentially skew the results and make them less accurate.
-
Specificity: The symptoms listed in the case definition are quite common and could be associated with a variety of diseases. This lack of specificity could lead to misdiagnosis or confusion.
-
Time Frame: The case definition includes a specific start date (October 1), but it does not specify an end date. This could potentially lead to confusion or inconsistency in data collection.
-
Lack of Operational Definitions: The case definition does not provide operational definitions for some of its terms, such as "high-grade fever" and "prostration". This could lead to inconsistency in how these terms are interpreted and applied.
-
No Consideration of Age, Gender, or Other Demographics: The case definition does not take into account the age, gender, or other demographic factors of the patients. This could potentially lead to bias or a lack of representativeness in the sample.
-
No Mention of Exclusion Criteria: The case definition does not mention any exclusion criteria. This could potentially lead to the inclusion of cases that should not be included in the study.
Similar Questions
find the strength and weakness of this paper Case definition When the team reached the field, we made a very broad case definition as a method to include as many diseased cases as possible for blood sample collection for testing and confirmation. Our field case definition was any patient who developed a sudden high-grade fever ≥38 ◦C with or without bleeding, jaundice, vomiting or prostration after October 1. We used this case definition to guide our hospital visits, to facilitate active household case searching and to assist with clinical records revision.
criticize Active case finding The team conducted a systematic active casefinding survey based on the above field case definition. The team visited the two main hospitals of the affected area (Nertiti rural hospital and Nyala) and actively assessed the present medical records, admission sheets, laboratory registers and pharmacy logbooks. Additionally, ‘‘shoe-leather epidemiology’’ was used for active case finding at the village and household levels within the residential areas from which the index cases were reported. The investigation team visited the following villages during the field outbreak investigation missions: • Khour Ramla, • Fukodoko, • Rijl Aldalaba, • Toor, • Tibbi, • Jurfambari, • Norma. Based on the above-mentioned case definition, the investigation team generated the initial outbreak line list. Nine additional cases were added as a result of active case finding, bringing the total to 16 cases for the initial line list. Fresh blood samples were collected from the acutely febrile patients during the household visits (the samples were used for serology and blood films for malaria). Descriptive epidemiology The team analyzed the data descriptively, applying the classical epidemiological traits of person, place and time to gain insights on the reported cases. One of the most interesting findings was that the majority (81.2%) of the cases were young adult males, were related and were in close contact with animals (38% pastoral). Another interesting finding was that most of the cases were initially treated with antimalarial medications, including the recommended treatmentlines that are based on a positive immuno chromatographic (ICT) test for Falciparum Malaria. Family history ofthe disease was confirmed because two families had reported the deaths of immediate family members during the investigation period and the illness had manifested identically in both, with fever and bleeding (hematemesis). Bleeding presented in 80% of cases, while jaundice presented in 19% of cases. Further descriptions of the overall outbreak and the other reported cases will be published separately (Figs. 1 and 2). Hypothesis generation Before laboratory confirmation of the collected blood samples, the investigators generated three hypotheses based on the available descriptions for the reported cases and the surrounding environment, in addition to information from previous
A case study is an example of:
4. What is a test case?
how to write case study
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.