Why did the Dred Scott case (1857) come to exemplify the “American dilemma”?A.The case represented the Asian American struggle against prejudice and discrimination.B.The Supreme Court ruled against white slave owners, denying them the social dominance to which they were accustomed.C.The ruling denied an entire category of people—African American slaves—basic rights and freedoms given to U.S. citizens.D.The ruling banned white ethnic Americans from well-paid industry jobs, denying them the privileges given to other ethnic groups
Question
Why did the Dred Scott case (1857) come to exemplify the “American dilemma”?A.The case represented the Asian American struggle against prejudice and discrimination.B.The Supreme Court ruled against white slave owners, denying them the social dominance to which they were accustomed.C.The ruling denied an entire category of people—African American slaves—basic rights and freedoms given to U.S. citizens.D.The ruling banned white ethnic Americans from well-paid industry jobs, denying them the privileges given to other ethnic groups
Solution
The Dred Scott case (1857) came to exemplify the “American dilemma” because of option C: The ruling denied an entire category of people—African American slaves—basic rights and freedoms given to U.S. citizens.
Here's a step-by-step explanation:
-
Dred Scott was a slave who sued for his freedom in the U.S. Supreme Court, arguing that he had lived in territories where slavery was illegal and therefore should be considered free.
-
The Supreme Court ruled against Scott, stating that African Americans, whether free or enslaved, could not be American citizens and therefore had no standing to sue in federal court.
-
The court also ruled that the federal government had no power to regulate slavery in the federal territories acquired after the creation of the United States.
-
This decision intensified ongoing debates about slavery, contributing to rising tensions between the North and South that eventually led to the American Civil War.
-
The case exemplified the "American dilemma" because it highlighted the stark contradiction between the nation's professed ideals of freedom and equality and the reality of racial discrimination and slavery.
Similar Questions
What was the Dred Scott decision?A.A court ruling that made Dred Scott a free man instead of a slaveB.A federal law that made racial hierarchy in the United States legalC.A Virginia state law that established the legal practice of racial privilegeD.A Supreme Court ruling stating that Blacks could not become citizens of the United States
Why was the Dred Scott case so important? Why did it increase tensions in the US?
In the Dred Scott Case, the Supreme Court ruled that Mr. Scott was not free because what took precedence over everything else? A. the appellate court B. the Fugitive Slave Law C. a property owner’s rights D. Manifest Destiny
In the controversial Dredd Scott decision, the Supreme Court declared that:Group of answer choicesneither enslaved or free Black Americans had the right to become citizensBlack Americans were free only when they entered free territoryDred Scott did not have the right to file a suitonly Congress had the right to regulate slavery in the states and territories
In the Dred Scott v. Sandford case, the Supreme Court ruled that:A.slavery could not be practiced in any new states or territories.B.African Americans had no legal rights in the United States.C.the legality of slavery should be left up to state governments.D.states had the right to ignore federal laws they opposed.
Upgrade your grade with Knowee
Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.