As a study assistant, I can provide a hypothetical example of how a Dissertation Supervisor might provide feedback on a student's ability to search and critically appraise academic literatures, organise data and evidence, and apply these to an extended literature review.

1. **Search and Critically Appraise Academic Literatures**: "Your literature search is comprehensive and you have identified key studies in your field. However, your critical appraisal needs improvement. While you have summarised the studies well, you need to delve deeper into evaluating the methodologies used, the validity of the findings, and how these studies contribute to the field. Remember, critical appraisal is not just about identifying the strengths of a study, but also its limitations."

2. **Organising Data and Evidence**: "Your organisation of data and evidence is clear and logical. You have done well in categorising the studies according to themes and presenting them in a coherent manner. However, there are instances where you could have made better use of tables or charts to present your data. Visual representation of data can often make it easier for readers to understand your findings."

3. **Applying to an Extended Literature Review**: "Your application of the studies to your literature review is generally good. You have shown how each study contributes to your research question. However, you need to work on creating a more cohesive narrative that ties all your studies together. At times, it feels like you are listing studies rather than integrating them into your review. Remember, the goal of a literature review is not just to summarise existing studies, but to build an argument for your own research."

Remember, this is just a hypothetical example and actual feedback may vary based on the specific requirements of your dissertation and the preferences of your supervisor.

Question

As a study assistant, I can provide a hypothetical example of how a Dissertation Supervisor might provide feedback on a student's ability to search and critically appraise academic literatures, organise data and evidence, and apply these to an extended literature review.

1. **Search and Critically Appraise Academic Literatures**: "Your literature search is comprehensive and you have identified key studies in your field. However, your critical appraisal needs improvement. While you have summarised the studies well, you need to delve deeper into evaluating the methodologies used, the validity of the findings, and how these studies contribute to the field. Remember, critical appraisal is not just about identifying the strengths of a study, but also its limitations."

2. **Organising Data and Evidence**: "Your organisation of data and evidence is clear and logical. You have done well in categorising the studies according to themes and presenting them in a coherent manner. However, there are instances where you could have made better use of tables or charts to present your data. Visual representation of data can often make it easier for readers to understand your findings."

3. **Applying to an Extended Literature Review**: "Your application of the studies to your literature review is generally good. You have shown how each study contributes to your research question. However, you need to work on creating a more cohesive narrative that ties all your studies together. At times, it feels like you are listing studies rather than integrating them into your review. Remember, the goal of a literature review is not just to summarise existing studies, but to build an argument for your own research."

Remember, this is just a hypothetical example and actual feedback may vary based on the specific requirements of your dissertation and the preferences of your supervisor.

Knowee AI · Accepted Answer

As a study assistant, I can provide a hypothetical example of how a Dissertation Supervisor might provide feedback on a student's ability to search and critically appraise academic literatures, organise data and evidence, and apply these to an extended literature review.

1. **Search and Critically Appraise Academic Literatures**: "Your literature search is comprehensive and you have identified key studies in your field. However, your critical appraisal needs improvement. While you have summarised the studies well, you need to delve deeper into evaluating the methodologies used, the validity of the findings, and how these studies contribute to the field. Remember, critical appraisal is not just about identifying the strengths of a study, but also its limitations."

2. **Organising Data and Evidence**: "Your organisation of data and evidence is clear and logical. You have done well in categorising the studies according to themes and presenting them in a coherent manner. However, there are instances where you could have made better use of tables or charts to present your data. Visual representation of data can often make it easier for readers to understand your findings."

3. **Applying to an Extended Literature Review**: "Your application of the studies to your literature review is generally good. You have shown how each study contributes to your research question. However, you need to work on creating a more cohesive narrative that ties all your studies together. At times, it feels like you are listing studies rather than integrating them into your review. Remember, the goal of a literature review is not just to summarise existing studies, but to build an argument for your own research."

Remember, this is just a hypothetical example and actual feedback may vary based on the specific requirements of your dissertation and the preferences of your supervisor.

"Example of Dissertation Supervisor's feedback on Search and critically appraise academic literatures, organising data and evidence, applying to an extended literature Review"

Question

Solution

Similar Questions

Upgrade your grade with Knowee