Knowee
Questions
Features
Study Tools

integrate: All stories have a curious and even dangerous power. They are manifestations of truth — yours and mine. And truth is all at once the most wonderful yet terrifying thing in the world, which makes it nearly impossible to handle. It is such a great responsibility that it’s best not to tell a story at all unless you know you can do it right. You must be very careful, or without knowing it you can change the world.” ― Vera Nazarian, Dreams of the Compass Rose into:War. Corruption. Death. This is our society today. This is the corrupt state of our degrading world. All around the globe there are wars, death, tyrannical leaders and political dramas. But I guarantee you almost everyone will have their own view on war. Composers often use their narratives to their advantage by portraying their personal opinions and views on certain topics. This grants their narratives the ability to inspire an individual's opinions and viewpoints. Next slide The amount of narratives written on war is immense. Out of all of them, one that I found to have a great influence on my perspective on war was written by John McCrae in the spring of 1915, “In Flanders Fields”. The poem was centralised around the motif of poppies, which is universally known as a symbol of patriotic remembrance for the death and agony arising from wartime expeditions. Point at the first line. The very first line introduces the key symbol of the poppy and also demonstrates the literal truth that the natural world continues to produce new life, no matter the circumstances. The flowers themselves, then, are the poem's first hint that life and death are intimately connected and perhaps even inseparable. The juxtaposing image of the "crosses" and the “poppies” reinforces this notion of life and death allowing the composer to optimistically express how after the death in war, life will flourish. This gives readers a deeper understanding of the sardonic worldview that war is a necessity as an equaliser of corruption and peace in the natural world and hence creates a connection between life and death. In the same stanza, (POINT TO THE BOARD) the speaker’s repetition of "row on row" creates the sense that the graves here are endless, just like the flowers. This clashes with the previous lines as even though life will flourish afterwards, death will always have a greater impact on individuals. Here the composer expresses how the result of war is a bloodbath, and hence paradoxically expresses his personal condemnation of war arising from corruption and anarchy. Next slide Often composers expediently use their narratives to compel readers to empathise with an unknown or unfamiliar perspective.Ben Affleck’s “Argo” (2012) does exactly this by manipulating audiences to develop an antagonistic view on Iranians through attributing their theocratic social structure to being a catalyst to corruption and oppression in their country. However, he also attributes their oppression as a vehicle to alienate outsiders and cultivate a stronger sense of community among civilians. Next slide When we first watched this scene we all noticed the burning flag. But what is even more interesting is the way it is positioned. We can see here that the Iranian who is holding the flag is positioned in a place of more power as they are above the flag. Here, Affleck portrays the Iranians as violent, irrational and threatening in nature, as they are burning the flag. In fact Iranians are depicted as uncivilised and dangerous people in the rest of the film as well. Throughout the film we as the audience are influenced to have pessimistic views on Iran. Next slide A few minutes in, the composer emphasises the barbaric nature of the Iranians. Affleck shows how the Iranians’ barbarism and the corruption of their authoritarian leader adversely affects its nation. The anger in the Iranian’s face is shown thoroughly to express their true thoughts on the Americans, and to show how the distrust of outsiders and fear of acting out of line is the result of a tyrannical ruler. This further reinforces Affleck's personal opinions on war, and highlights his hatred towards Iran. Next slide All of you here have been impacted, even if it was in the slightest way, by this speech. This is the power of literature. Specifically the power of narratives. It has the scary ability to manipulate our thoughts and our world. And throughout our lives, narratives have made us the people we are today. Thank you for listening.

Question

integrate: All stories have a curious and even dangerous power. They are manifestations of truth — yours and mine. And truth is all at once the most wonderful yet terrifying thing in the world, which makes it nearly impossible to handle. It is such a great responsibility that it’s best not to tell a story at all unless you know you can do it right. You must be very careful, or without knowing it you can change the world.” ― Vera Nazarian, Dreams of the Compass Rose into:War. Corruption. Death. This is our society today. This is the corrupt state of our degrading world. All around the globe there are wars, death, tyrannical leaders and political dramas. But I guarantee you almost everyone will have their own view on war. Composers often use their narratives to their advantage by portraying their personal opinions and views on certain topics. This grants their narratives the ability to inspire an individual's opinions and viewpoints. Next slide The amount of narratives written on war is immense. Out of all of them, one that I found to have a great influence on my perspective on war was written by John McCrae in the spring of 1915, “In Flanders Fields”. The poem was centralised around the motif of poppies, which is universally known as a symbol of patriotic remembrance for the death and agony arising from wartime expeditions. Point at the first line. The very first line introduces the key symbol of the poppy and also demonstrates the literal truth that the natural world continues to produce new life, no matter the circumstances. The flowers themselves, then, are the poem's first hint that life and death are intimately connected and perhaps even inseparable. The juxtaposing image of the "crosses" and the “poppies” reinforces this notion of life and death allowing the composer to optimistically express how after the death in war, life will flourish. This gives readers a deeper understanding of the sardonic worldview that war is a necessity as an equaliser of corruption and peace in the natural world and hence creates a connection between life and death. In the same stanza, (POINT TO THE BOARD) the speaker’s repetition of "row on row" creates the sense that the graves here are endless, just like the flowers. This clashes with the previous lines as even though life will flourish afterwards, death will always have a greater impact on individuals. Here the composer expresses how the result of war is a bloodbath, and hence paradoxically expresses his personal condemnation of war arising from corruption and anarchy. Next slide Often composers expediently use their narratives to compel readers to empathise with an unknown or unfamiliar perspective.Ben Affleck’s “Argo” (2012) does exactly this by manipulating audiences to develop an antagonistic view on Iranians through attributing their theocratic social structure to being a catalyst to corruption and oppression in their country. However, he also attributes their oppression as a vehicle to alienate outsiders and cultivate a stronger sense of community among civilians. Next slide When we first watched this scene we all noticed the burning flag. But what is even more interesting is the way it is positioned. We can see here that the Iranian who is holding the flag is positioned in a place of more power as they are above the flag. Here, Affleck portrays the Iranians as violent, irrational and threatening in nature, as they are burning the flag. In fact Iranians are depicted as uncivilised and dangerous people in the rest of the film as well. Throughout the film we as the audience are influenced to have pessimistic views on Iran. Next slide A few minutes in, the composer emphasises the barbaric nature of the Iranians. Affleck shows how the Iranians’ barbarism and the corruption of their authoritarian leader adversely affects its nation. The anger in the Iranian’s face is shown thoroughly to express their true thoughts on the Americans, and to show how the distrust of outsiders and fear of acting out of line is the result of a tyrannical ruler. This further reinforces Affleck's personal opinions on war, and highlights his hatred towards Iran. Next slide All of you here have been impacted, even if it was in the slightest way, by this speech. This is the power of literature. Specifically the power of narratives. It has the scary ability to manipulate our thoughts and our world. And throughout our lives, narratives have made us the people we are today. Thank you for listening.

...expand
🧐 Not the exact question you are looking for?Go ask a question

Solution

The power of narratives is beautifully encapsulated in Vera Nazarian's quote. Stories, as she suggests, are manifestations of truth, and they have the potential to change the world. This is evident in our society today, which is riddled with war, corruption, and death. Everyone has their own perspective on these issues, and narratives often serve as a platform for composers to express their personal views and opinions.

John McCrae's poem "In Flanders Fields" is a prime example of this. The poem uses the symbol of poppies to represent the cycle of life and death in war. The juxtaposition of the crosses and poppies in the poem highlights the paradoxical nature of war, which brings about both destruction and renewal.

Similarly, Ben Affleck's film "Argo" uses narrative to present a particular perspective on the Iranian society. The film portrays Iranians as violent and threatening, and their theocratic social structure as a source of corruption and oppression. This narrative compels the audience to empathize with an unfamiliar perspective and develop an antagonistic view of Iranians.

In conclusion, narratives have a profound impact on our thoughts and perceptions. They shape our understanding of the world and influence our attitudes towards various issues. As Nazarian suggests, it is a great responsibility to tell a story, as it has the potential to change the world.

This problem has been solved

Similar Questions

The passage given below is followed by four summaries. Choose the option that best captures the essence of the text. While many people believe that myths are stories that are ‘untrue’ or even ‘lies,’ in fact, resonant mythologies are metaphors that provide us with symbols of a life we long to experience. Mythological narratives may or may not be based in fact. Myths that are temporal will cease to inspire over time and will die out. The perennial myths, however, are those which persevere and project a timeless truth which point the way to our ultimate destiny. To pursue this destiny is the hero’s journey. Myths are stories, true or untrue, that help us to drag ourselves out of drudgery and despair to pursue a higher calling and awaken the hero in us.Resonant mythologies represent the eternal truth, and while temporal myths peter out, perennial myths transcend limitations of time, inspiring the hero to pursue the higher truth.Myths begin where human limitations of time and ability end, and perennial myths motivate us to embark on an epical journey to seek salvation in our own way.Resonant mythologies are great inspirational stories that resonate with us in our subconscious, where our identity becomes the hero, who is destined to pursue the truth.

In some of the texts we have read so far in this class (e.g. Frederick Douglass's "Learning to Read and Write," Ericsson's "The Ways We Lie,"), as well as the videos (like Sam Harris's "Why You Should Commit to Telling the Truth" and Donald Hoffman's "Do we see reality as it is?") one theme has been the uses and limits of truth and knowledge. We have seen the ways in which knowledge and truth can be both a blessing and a burden, how they can be used to better understand our circumstances or to manipulate other people, even ourselves.With this in mind, answer the following question: how have knowledge and truth helped you achieve your personal goals and enabled you to live a better life? Have they ever been a burden to you (say, in the way deep understanding was temporarily despairing to Douglass)? Have you ever ignored or distorted truth and knowledge in order to get something you wanted, in the way Ericsson says we sometimes do?  You must explore these questions in your essay, making reference to at least 2 of the essays or videos we have discussed

“Narratives have the power to explore the highest and lowest points of humanity, exposing fundamental truths about the human spirit” Discuss this statement with close reference to Markus Zusak’s The Book Thief.

What kind of information belongs in a summary of a story?several direct quotes from the storya long analysis of the story’s meaningonly a statement of the story’s themethe most important events and details

“Narratives have the power to explore the highest and lowest points of humanity, exposing fundamental truths about the human spirit” Discuss this statement with close reference to Markus Zusak’s The Book Thief in an essay

1/1

Upgrade your grade with Knowee

Get personalized homework help. Review tough concepts in more detail, or go deeper into your topic by exploring other relevant questions.